1. OnPay — Best Overall Gusto Alternative
Simple, transparent payroll without the bloat
OnPay is what Gusto should have stayed: simple, powerful payroll for small businesses that don't need 50 HR modules. The interface is cleaner, the pricing is more transparent, and the customer support is legendary (real humans who actually answer!).
What makes OnPay special is its focus on doing payroll really well instead of trying to be everything. You get full-service payroll (including tax filing), time tracking, benefits administration, and HR essentials—but without the overwhelming feature sprawl that makes Gusto feel like homework.
The onboarding is smooth (2-3 business days vs. Gusto's sometimes week-long setup), and the mobile app is actually intuitive. Plus, OnPay includes HR support and new hire reporting at no extra cost—features Gusto charges for. It integrates seamlessly with QuickBooks, Xero, and most accounting software.
The main limitation? If you need advanced performance management tools or sophisticated org charts, you'll need to supplement with another tool. But for 90% of small businesses, OnPay hits the sweet spot of powerful and simple.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it hard to switch from Gusto?
Not really. Most alternatives offer migration support. Expect 1-2 payroll cycles of overlap to ensure everything transfers smoothly. OnPay and Rippling both have dedicated migration teams.
Will I lose my payroll history?
No. You can export your payroll history from Gusto and most platforms will import it (or at least store it for reference). Your W-2s and tax filings remain accessible.
What if I just need payroll, not HR?
Go with OnPay or Wave Payroll. Both focus on payroll without forcing you to buy HR modules you don't need.
Can I really save money switching?
Depends on your usage. If you're paying for Gusto add-ons you don't need, yes. OnPay's transparent pricing often saves money. But if you need extensive HR features, you might not save much.
Need help deciding?
Read our in-depth reviews and comparison guides